Get Advice
Ask our automotive experts your car questions
Get Certified
Get your location
Certified Female Friendly®!
Keep up with Patty
Visit AskPatty on
these other sites
Facebook
Flickr
LinkedIn
Social Pressroom
RSS Feed
Twitter
Youtube
More Items
EatonWeb Blog Directory
About Ask Patty Blog Podcasts Advice Press Partners Insurance  
Home Community My Ez Car Care Get A Quote Career Center Get Certified

« GM Hydrogen Fuel-Cell Vehicle: from concept to market | Main | Car Buying Tips To Help with Your Holiday Season Car Purchase »

October 19, 2007

Should Parents be Banned from Smoking?

Smoking Recently, we reported on the California ban on smoking in cars when minors are present. Motorists caught face a fine of up to $100, but can’t be cited unless they are stopped for another infraction. The ban takes effect January 1. California is the third state to pass a law attempting to protect children from secondhand smoke.

I’m actually torn on the issue. We already have laws in place to protect children in cars, such as requiring car safety seats. So this new law is just one addition to protect our precious children. Or is it?

The bill also prohibits smoking in other places, like within 25 feet of a playground and in certain workspaces. And it further restricts the rights of smokers. So are we protecting the rights of non-smokers to not breathe secondhand smoke, or are we just taking away more and more rights from smokers? It’s a fine line to walk, isn’t it?

I am not a smoker. I never have been. My husband quit since we found out we’re having a baby, but he never smoked in the house or in our vehicles when I was present. And he wouldn’t have smoked when our child is in the car.

But what about parents that do? Do they have the right to smoke in their own vehicle? Or do their children’s rights to breathe smoke-free air trump the parent’s right to smoke? A report last year said secondhand smoke is more of a health risk in a car than it is in a home. So whose rights are more important?

Since kids, especially infants, can’t choose not to breathe smoke, a parent should take that into consideration when smoking. But does every parent? No. But neither does every parent make their child stay seated and strapped into a booster or safety seat, even though there are laws to that effect. So, will a ban on smoking in cars really deter a parent who wants to smoke? Probably not, until they actually get hit with a $100 fine. And even then, it may not stop them from repeat offenses.

There’s a heated discussion about this topic going on over at Maya’s Mom, where readers are taking opposite sides of the debate.

So what do you think, is this a worthwhile law? Will it get ignored? Should it even be a law at all? Are we restricting smokers too much? We’d love to hear your opinion.

Source: Yahoo

Photo courtesy of joka2000.

Becky_headshot By Becky Scott
Contributing Editor


Visit us at AskPatty.com


blog comments powered by Disqus
Winner - 2010 DMS Contributor Award
Winner - Excellence in Blogging 2010




Women Blog Directory
©2009 AskPatty.com, Inc.| P.O. Box 6601 Thousand Oaks, CA 91359 | Phone 888-745-1928 | Email info@AskPatty.com

This site, its contents and all related content, formats and documents are copyrighted property of AskPatty.com, Inc and are not to be reproduced or republished without the written consent of AskPatty.com, Inc.

About Ask Patty Blog Womanars FAQ's Privacy Policy Links Pressroom Partners Advertise on Ask Patty